Cocktail Sauce

This cocktail sauce is made with tomato paste mixed with our own fresh ground horseradish for a smooth tangy taste! Traditionally served with shrimp, crab, oysters and fried seafood.

Flavor profile

Look no further for the Cocktail Sauce that sticks to your seafood. Our fresh horseradish and zesty tomato flavor will not disappoint.

Tomato Paste, Water, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Distilled Vinegar, Horseradish, Salt, Lemon Juice Concentrate, Soybean Oil, Beet Powder, Natural Flavor & Artificial Flavor, Xanthan Gum, Potassium Sorbate and Sodium Benzoate (used as preservatives), and EDTA- Calcium Disodium (to protect quality).

Steamed shrimp, Oysters, Crab cakes, Fried clam strips, Meatballs

Bacon Wrapped Meatloaf Balls

Cocktail Meatball Sandwiches

Cocktail Sauce Shrimp Platter

Grilled Seafood Personal Pizza

Seacuterie Board

Western Omelet with Bookbinder's Cocktail Sauce

  • Best Cocktail sauce

    By Janis Howman from Ohio
    January 3, 2024

    Bookbinders is the best cocktail sauce! I can't wait to make more shrimp dip! ????

  • Food

    By Brittiany from Dallas
    December 27, 2023

    The best I ever had

  • Mrs.

    By Melinda Russell, Charlotte, NC
    November 18, 2021

    I used to make my own cocktail sauce, which I will say was quite good. Picked this up at Sam's Club .... not only have I NOT made my own sauce since then, I don't even know where my old recipe is anymore.

  • Ms

    By Erin Stewart from Pennsylu
    April 11, 2021

    Sooo.....are we just gonna act like this isn’t the best thing to happen to battered shrimp since hot grease. I picked this bottle up on a whim opting for Bookbinders over the store brand cocktail sauce of the same price. Let. Me. Tell. You. From the first taste of this sauce on my shrimp I had to pause and find somebody to tell how unexpectedly DELICIOUS this cocktail sauce is. I tried telling my girlfriend, woke my kids up to have them try it—all thought it was good but none shared my passion for the taste. So, I had to come online and post a comment. EAT THIS SAUCE.

  • Ms

    By Darlene Nicholson from Satellite Beach, Florida
    February 7, 2021

    My husband and I love shrimp cocktail and Bookbinder’s is the absolute best. We don’t use anything else!

  • RETIRED CLINICAL NUTRIONIST

    By AGNES M CANZONA from WINSTON-SALEM, NC
    December 26, 2020

    MY DAUGHTER BOUGHT THE SEAFOOD COCKTAIL SAUCE FROM PUBLIX. THE SAUCE IS GREAT! SO MUCH FLAVOR.
    VISITING THE ORIGINAL BOOKBINDERS WAS ON MY "BUCKET LIST" FOR DECADES & I NEVER GOT THERE. AT LEAST I CAN ENJOY THE SAUCES.

  • Home Maker

    By Terry Jacobs from Cincinnati
    September 11, 2020

    I agree with the other person who was upset that Sam's Club wasn't carrying Bookbinder's cocktail sauce any longer. We are seafood lover's and Bookbinder's is the only cocktail sauce that I will use. I don't want to just buy those small jars, it would be too much waste to have all of those jars to dispose of. I prefer to purchase the larger jar that last awhile.

  • Bookbinder’s Hot & Spicy Cocktail Sauce

    By Hattie Ann from Arvada Colorado
    July 11, 2020

    All the stores anywhere near me no longer carry my favorite cocktail sauce...cannot enjoy shrimp cocktail without it. Has it been discontinued?

  • Title?

    By connie from 2882
    June 6, 2020

    Love this product. I'm a foodie, I'm like a chef Ramsey type. Most time I have to make what I want at home, because I'm always disappointed however this cocktail sauce is the best I have tried in 14 years.

  • Love your cocktail sauce, but can't find it anywhere!!!

    By Karen from Parkville, MO
    June 4, 2020

    Looks like I'm not the only one who is VERY disappointed that Sam's Club is not carrying Bookbinder's cocktail sauce. Walmart does not have it in stock either. Would order it on Amazon, but I need it in 2 days and can't get it quick enough...NOT happy!! Love that sauce!!

  • Finally found it

    By Msc from Oklahoma
    May 13, 2020

    I ordered the 32oz off amazon. Only place I could find it

  • Finally found it

    By Msc from Oklahoma
    May 13, 2020

    I ordered the 32oz off amazon. Only place I could find it

  • Mrs.

    By Kate from Ohio
    February 8, 2020

    We really like this! Our Sam's Club stopped carrying!! What the heck! Where can I buy this in N.E. Ohio?

  • jerrynmary

    By Jerry Henderlite from Chesapeake Va.
    January 29, 2020

    Bookbinders cocktail is the best cocktail sauce I have ever had . Sams Club no longer has it . This is a minus for sams club and I do not think we will renew our membership . This is so like sams club and one of many things we liked at sams club that they do not carry anymore. I think others should think about their membership also. WAY TO GO AGAIN SAMS.

  • Can't find your cocktail sauce

    By K Erickson from Denver
    January 29, 2020

    I have been buying your cocktail sauce for over 30 years in Denver. Now Sam's, King Soopers and Safeway don't carry it! It is the best where in Denver can I still buy it! Loyal customer! Kim

  • mrs

    By Pamela Ewald from OH
    January 25, 2020

    As with many others, I'm upset that Sam's no longer carries your cocktail sauce. Besides being the best, I liked being able to purchase the 32Oz. size

  • DISAPPOINTED IN SAM'S CLUB

    By Sonya from Florida from Florida
    January 11, 2020

    Went to Sam's Club yesterday to purchase seafood and Bookbinder's Cocktail Sauce. Disappointed to find Sam's Club is no longer carrying product again. This is the best sauce I have ever used. Guess I will have to start making my own again. Sam's Club has discontinued carrying so many product favorites that I may not renew my membership after 15+ years as a member.

  • Mrs

    By Diane Lee from Newington, CT
    January 6, 2020

    This is bad news....what was Sam's Club thinking? By far, your cocktail sauce is the best.....so disappointed they decided not to carry it any longer. They still sell fish and no cocktail sauce.......not good marketing on their point. This was not a good way to start 2020 for me!! :-(

  • Jason's smoked meats

    By Jason Wallin from Nebraska
    December 30, 2019

    I miss the large size that you could get at Sam's Club. Bookbinder's Cocktail Sauce was the closest to my homemade. Guess I will have to start making my own again.???? Is there another store in the Omaha, NE. area that is selling the large size?

  • Disappointed in Sam's

    By Jerry from Florida
    December 30, 2019

    Like many of the other comments, I'm disappointed your product is no longer carried at Sam's. Best cocktail sauce out there!

  • So sad

    By Cathie Gentry from Murrieta, ca
    December 26, 2019

    We lived this cocktail sauce ans so sorry sams is no longer selling! I would pay the 12.00 as someone mentioned. Hello Costco... can you sell this 8f Sam's has given up? Where else can we buy this???

  • User

    By Ronald Jacobs from Daytona Beach Florida
    November 29, 2019

    Tried your cocktail sauce on a whim last year from Sam's Club. It is the best I have ever tasted. I have used the last bit I had and now I am very disappointed that Sam's discontinued selling it. What were they thinking---stupid decision on their part.

  • Homemaker

    By Betty from Brownstown, Michigan
    November 25, 2019

    I am very disappointed Sam's Club is no longer carrying your product. I will have to purchase it somewhere else, I can't have my holiday meals without it!

  • Ms

    By Lorries66 from Georgia
    November 9, 2019

    I miss the large size that you could get at Sam's Club. Bookbinder's Cocktail Sauce was the closest to my homemade. Guess I will have to start making my own again.????

  • Goodbye Ketchup

    By Bruce E Biggins from Ft.Lauderdale
    October 21, 2019

    I am 65 , and retired . My one meal ( 14:00 dinner) is fish one night , turkey / chicken (burgers , thighs) the next . Back and forth . I was using regular , generic ketchup , for decades . A few months ago , accidentally used Bookbinders . I use it exclusively now . A wonderful product .

  • homemaker

    By Sandy Nelis from Holland Mi'
    October 15, 2019

    I was very disappointed that Sams stopped selling your cocktail sauce. It is the best. I'll call your company to see who might be carrying it in our area

  • Chef, retired

    By BRADFORD Jay SPENCER from CT
    October 3, 2019

    This cocktail sauce is by far the best in the country. I'm not sure why but Sams club has discontinued as of 4 weeks ago. I will not be shopping at Sam's club because of this reason. What are they thinking at their corporate office ?

  • Mrs.

    By Lorraine Sparveri from AZ
    September 28, 2019

    I agree with others who commented about Sams Club not carrying Book Binders cocktail sauce. I stopped buy my shrimp at Sam's because they don't carry this sauce.

  • Love this stuff!

    By Joanne Alexander from South Carolina
    September 15, 2019

    I agree with others about the disappointment that Sam's Club is no longer selling Bookbinder's Cocktail Sauce. I live along the SC coast and a variety of cocktail sauces are available but none are acceptable taste-wise to my family, except Bookbinde'r. I sure wish it was still at Sam's. Used to buy several quart jars at a time, and recommend to others when they couldn't believe it wasn't my own homemade secret recipe!

  • Personal use

    By Douglas from Dothan, Alabama
    September 1, 2019

    I have stopped buying shrimp at Sam's since your cocktail sauce (00034) is no longer available.

    Please begin "once again" to sell your cocktail sauce to Sams.
    Thank you...Doug

  • cocktail sauce...

    By billy d lindig from Arizona
    August 25, 2019

    Sam's club stopped selling it because they were selling it too cheap 4 dollars a jar. If Sams brought it back it would be $12 to $15 dollars a jar.

  • Bookbinders cocktail sauce

    By Ric Scialabba from NC
    August 23, 2019

    I was so disappointed to learn that Sam’s Club is no longer carrying your cocktail sauce. I agree with many others that I t is the best I have ever had! Please bring it back to Sam’s Clubs!!! SO DISAPPOINTED

  • Ms

    By Debby King from Fairmont, WV
    August 14, 2019

    We used to buy our Bookbinders at Sam's clubs....Oh how I miss that cocktail sauce!!
    Best cocktail sauce we've ever had!!
    Hopefully if enough of us request Sams' Clubs to carry it once again, we may once again be able to get it there!!

  • Consumer

    By Pam from Brandon, FL
    July 25, 2019

    I was so disappointed to learn that Sam’s Club is no longer carrying your cocktail sauce. I agree with many others that I t is the best I have ever had! Please bring it back to Sam’s Clubs!!!

  • Mrs

    By Mary Allen from Eunice, NM
    June 16, 2019

    Sams Club in Midland, Texas no longer carries this cocktail sauce, where can I find a store that carries it?

  • Bookbinder’s Cocktail Sauce

    By Sandra from Schoolcraft, Mi.
    June 2, 2019

    My family and I used to buy this awesome cocktail sauce at Sam’s Club, but our Portage store no longer carries it. Can you tell me where I can purchase it in Southwest Michigan, or if I will have to purchase it online? Thank you!

  • Agree with the others

    By geo pet from Colorado
    March 2, 2019

    YES, this is THE best cocktail sauce I've ever had. A perfect amount of horseradish: not too hot, jusssst right!

  • Mr.

    By R Couples from Fort Myers, Florida
    January 24, 2019

    I previously purchased your cocktail sauce at Kroger in Michigan and Fry's in Arizona. I recently relocated to Fort Myers, Florida and have not been able to source it here. It's a great product and am wondering if any retailers carry it here. It pairs well with shrimp and I would like to serve it with our local Key West Pink Shrimp sourced from the Gulf of Mexico.

  • Ms

    By Samuel Plankmaker from Chicago IL
    December 7, 2018

    This seafood cocktail sauce was pungent. The horseradish really made it stand up and bark. Now that I have seen a range, I think I will probably stop subscribing.

  • Mr.

    By Don smith from Grand Rapids, mi
    September 14, 2018

    Probably the best cocktail I’ve had.

  • My

    By Mr Blake
    July 30, 2018

    Where in Michigan can you purchase the cocktail sauce

  • Mrs.

    By Christine from Indianapolis, IN
    March 16, 2018

    Is Bookbinder's Cocktail Sauce available at any grocery stores in indianapolis, IN. Approximately 3-5 years ago, I was able to purchase it at the Kroger stores. They haven't carried it in a long time.

  • Ms

    By Lori Shearier from 679 Depot St.
    December 31, 2017

    Is the date on the jar cover a sell by, use by or date made?

  • Retire

    By Denise from Kansas
    December 16, 2017

    This is great stuff but is it gluten free?

  • Retire

    By Denise from Kansas
    December 16, 2017

    This is great stuff but is it gluten free?

  • Ms.

    By LUAN LAEV from 1648 West Bradford Drive
    December 11, 2017

    why can't I get this fabulous cocktail sauce at local Milwaukee WI stores?
    Why don't you offer this sauce in GLASS CONTAINERS? i am not sure I want a SQUEEZE container.mm

  • Food lover

    By Lisa from Temperance, MI
    February 5, 2017

    Hands down...best cocktail sauce on the market! We live near the boarder of Toledo, OH and can't get this anywhere. They used to sell jumbo size in Sam's club...no more. Found in FL and took home a dozen small jars. Their sister co, makes a mean course ground horseradish. That also is the best we have ever found. A company that knowsits horseradish and how to use it! YUM. Please get the largest grocer..Krogers to carry both products!

  • retired hospital pharmacist administrator

    By richard sotak from albuquerque, new mexico
    January 18, 2017

    Absolutely the best cocktail sauce on the market.

  • Retired

    By Elaine Kermes from Orange Co, CA
    December 9, 2016

    Discovered this a few yrs ago in the Dollar store!!!! have not seen it since & it is available nowhere within 100 mi (so I read) The best cocktail sauce ever! why can't it return to CA?

  • Mrs

    By Melinda from Texas
    November 19, 2016

    Totaly agree with Becky from Texas! I have enjoyed this cocktail sauce for years and, all of a sudden it has disappeared from my local stores! It is the best ever. Please work with the Texas stores (Central Market,
    Albertson's, Tom Thumb, etc.) to make it available... I will order it until then!

  • Mr.

    By Gary from GA
    November 11, 2016

    retains it's flavor until the jar is empty. Other national brands I've tried by the middle of the jar they are just ketchup.

  • Ms

    By Helen Knox from Palm Harbor, Florida
    October 12, 2016

    Best cocktail sauce I've ever tasted.

  • Mrs.

    By Rosemary Parriott from Plattsmouth, Ne.
    September 4, 2016

    Love this product but cannot find it at stores where I usually shop, Dollar tree or Bakers. In Bellvue, Ne area. Bakers carries the hot and spicey. Can you help?

  • n/a

    By Becky from Texas
    August 13, 2016

    Best cocktail sauce I have ever tasted. Every person whom I had try it said the same thing. You most certainly have a winner with this! Now please put it in the Texas stores!

Add a comment: Cocktail Sauce

Fields marked with an asterisk (*) are required.

Learn more about us

Learn about our humble beginnings

Our Story