Horseradish, Mustards & Sauces

Cocktail Sauce

This cocktail sauce is made with tomato paste mixed with our own fresh ground horseradish for a smooth tangy taste! Traditionally served with shrimp, crab, oysters and fried seafood.

Ingredients

Tomato Paste, Water, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Distilled Vinegar, Horseradish, Salt, Lemon Juice Concentrate, Soybean Oil, Beet Powder, Natural Flavor & Artificial Flavor, Xanthan Gum, Potassium Sorbate and Sodium Benzoate (used as preservatives), and EDTA- Calcium Disodium (to protect quality).

Flavor Profile

Look no further for the Cocktail Sauce that sticks to your seafood. Our fresh horseradish and zesty tomato flavor will not disappoint.

Pairs Well With

Steamed shrimp (see recipe image)
Oysters
Crab cakes
Fried clam strips
Meatballs

100
love it 38
comments

Select a packing format:

3-Pack
(Mix-n-Match Available)

6-Pack
(Mix-n-Match Available)

9-Pack

How Many Would You Like?

$9.00

Add to Shopping Bag

Comments about Cocktail Sauce

View All Comments (38) Make a Comment

DISAPPOINTED IN SAM'S CLUB

By Sonya from Florida from Florida
Jan 11, 2020

Went to Sam's Club yesterday to purchase seafood and Bookbinder's Cocktail Sauce. Disappointed to find Sam's Club is no longer carrying product again. This is the best sauce I have ever used. Guess I will have to start making my own again. Sam's Club has discontinued carrying so many product favorites that I may not renew my membership after 15+ years as a member.

Mrs

By Diane Lee from Newington, CT
Jan 6, 2020

This is bad news....what was Sam's Club thinking? By far, your cocktail sauce is the best.....so disappointed they decided not to carry it any longer. They still sell fish and no cocktail sauce.......not good marketing on their point. This was not a good way to start 2020 for me!! :-(

Jason's smoked meats

By Jason Wallin from Nebraska
Dec 30, 2019

I miss the large size that you could get at Sam's Club. Bookbinder's Cocktail Sauce was the closest to my homemade. Guess I will have to start making my own again.???? Is there another store in the Omaha, NE. area that is selling the large size?

Disappointed in Sam's

By Jerry from Florida
Dec 30, 2019

Like many of the other comments, I'm disappointed your product is no longer carried at Sam's. Best cocktail sauce out there!