Horseradish, Mustards & Sauces

Cocktail Sauce

This cocktail sauce is made with tomato paste mixed with our own fresh ground horseradish for a smooth tangy taste! Traditionally served with shrimp, crab, oysters and fried seafood.

Ingredients

Tomato Paste, Water, High Fructose Corn Syrup, Distilled Vinegar, Horseradish, Salt, Lemon Juice Concentrate, Soybean Oil, Beet Powder, Natural Flavor & Artificial Flavor, Xanthan Gum, Potassium Sorbate and Sodium Benzoate (used as preservatives), and EDTA- Calcium Disodium (to protect quality).

Flavor Profile

Look no further for the Cocktail Sauce that sticks to your seafood. Our fresh horseradish and zesty tomato flavor will not disappoint.

Pairs Well With

Steamed shrimp (see recipe image)
Oysters
Crab cakes
Fried clam strips
Meatballs

142
love it 51
comments

Select a packing format:

3-Pack
(Mix-n-Match Available)

6-Pack
(Mix-n-Match Available)

9-Pack

How Many Would You Like?

$0.00

Add to Shopping Bag

Comments about Cocktail Sauce

View All Comments (51) Make a Comment

By Erin Stewart from Pennsylu
Apr 11, 2021

Sooo.....are we just gonna act like this isn’t the best thing to happen to battered shrimp since hot grease. I picked this bottle up on a whim opting for Bookbinders over the store brand cocktail sauce of the same price. Let. Me. Tell. You. From the first taste of this sauce on my shrimp I had to pause and find somebody to tell how unexpectedly DELICIOUS this cocktail sauce is. I tried telling my girlfriend, woke my kids up to have them try it—all thought it was good but none shared my passion for the taste. So, I had to come online and post a comment. EAT THIS SAUCE.

By Darlene Nicholson from Satellite Beach, Florida
Feb 7, 2021

My husband and I love shrimp cocktail and Bookbinder’s is the absolute best. We don’t use anything else!

RETIRED CLINICAL NUTRIONIST

By AGNES M CANZONA from WINSTON-SALEM, NC
Dec 26, 2020

MY DAUGHTER BOUGHT THE SEAFOOD COCKTAIL SAUCE FROM PUBLIX. THE SAUCE IS GREAT! SO MUCH FLAVOR. VISITING THE ORIGINAL BOOKBINDERS WAS ON MY "BUCKET LIST" FOR DECADES & I NEVER GOT THERE. AT LEAST I CAN ENJOY THE SAUCES.

Home Maker

By Terry Jacobs from Cincinnati
Sep 11, 2020

I agree with the other person who was upset that Sam's Club wasn't carrying Bookbinder's cocktail sauce any longer. We are seafood lover's and Bookbinder's is the only cocktail sauce that I will use. I don't want to just buy those small jars, it would be too much waste to have all of those jars to dispose of. I prefer to purchase the larger jar that last awhile.